Bitcoin Is Batman™

Also: Marathon won't censor, investors jump regulations, four crypto ETPs

What you need to know today in crypto and beyond  June 1, 2021 Sponsored By:     Welcome to The Node.   If you were forwarded this newsletter and would like to receive it, sign up here.   Questions? Feedback? We'd love to hear from you! Simply reply to this email.   –Daniel Kuhn Today's must-reads Top Shelf CROSS DEPARTMENT: Financial authorities are sounding the alarm on cryptocurrency investments. Michael Hsu, the acting Comptroller of the Currency, said he would like U.S. officials to work in lockstep to set a "regulatory perimeter" for cryptocurrencies. A top official at the Central Bank of Ireland gave another data point, saying crypto growth is "of great concern." Finally, Stefan Ingves, the governor of Sweden's central bank, predicted crypto regulation will develop at different speeds in different markets. OVER THE COUNTER: Chinese brokerage platforms Tiger Brokers and Futu are planning to expand into crypto amid Beijing's crackdown, but only to serve clients outside mainland China, according to separate company earnings calls. Meanwhile, Chinese investors remain active in the crypto market, bypassing regulatory oversight by taking bets on domestic and foreign OTC desks. ETHICAL BITCOIN? Bitcoin mining firm Marathon Digital Holdings is reversing a decision to reject transactions associated with sanctioned entities, a type of on-chain censorship that was broadly criticized in the Bitcoin community. MaraPool, which described itself as an "OFAC (Office of Foreign Assets Control) compliant," will update to Bitcoin Core version 0.21.1 and validate all transactions on the blockchain "in the exact same way as all other miners who use the standard node," CEO Fred Thiel said. ALLEGATIONS: Clients who lost money on the Mt. Gox exchange can begin to vote on whether or not they will accept a civil rehabilitation proposal. Three initial coin offerings (ICO) – Sirin Labs, Stx Technologies Limited (Stox) and Leadcoin, which had raised a total $250 million and are all linked to entrepreneur Moshe Hogeg – are being sued in an Israeli court. Finally, Former Commodity Futures Trading Commission (CFTC) Chairman Timothy Massad said a disruption in U.S. dollar stablecoin tether (USDT) could lead to a similar "breaking the buck" scenario in crypto seen during the 2008 financial crisis, according to a Bloomberg op-ed.   FINANCIALIZATION: Four investment firms – WisdomTree, VanEck, 21Shares and the ETC Group – received approval to list crypto ETPs on the Euronext stock exchanges in Paris and Amsterdam. The financial products begin trading today.    –D.K. A message from Nexo Your digital assets deserve a savings account in their BEST INTEREST. Leading crypto lender Nexo treats you, your crypto and your fiat to industry-best Crypto & Fiat services, featuring:    * Up to 12% interest on digital assets, paid out daily! * Yields available on BTC, ETH, LTC, BCH, XRP, XLM, EOS, TRX, LINK, BNB, PAXG, USDT, USDC, TUSD, PAX, DAI, HUSD, GBP and EUR. * No minimum or maximum limits on funds deposited, offering infinite opportunities to earn. * #ZeroFees on all transactions. * Military-grade wallet security and top-tier insurance on all custodial assets with SOC 2 Type 2 certified crypto custodian BitGo.   Get started at nexo.io Overheard on CoinDesk TV... Sound Bites "The next level of innovation will, frankly, give a whole new group of Americans access to the financial system. Hopefully, so they can grow their own freedom."   –Rep. Tom Emmer of Minnesota, on CoinDesk TV's "First Mover." A message from CoinDesk CoinDesk's new reward token soft-launched at Consensus 2021, but $DESK lives on. Attendees can still cash in at the $DESK store, or hodl and accumulate. Join the Telegram group for announcements and airdrops. What others are writing... Off-Chain Signals   "The debate over bitcoin exchange-traded funds, or ETFs, will be an important indicator of how far Washington is willing to let digital currency markets flourish amid growing questions about whether crypto serves any value to society or is just a speculative fad that carries real risks for investors." (Politco) South Korean crypto traders sent at least 64 trillion won (US$57.9 billion) from their bank accounts to crypto exchanges last quarter. That's 74% more than all of 2020 (Protos) The Reserve Bank of India has clarified that banks can't caution their customers against dealing in crypto, citing a 2018 circular (The Block) Chinese bitcoin mining hardware maker Canaan Creative said, in its Q1 financial report, that the overseas market accounted for nearly four-fifths of its sales in the quarter. (The Block) –D.K. Circle your calendar. Art collectors are projected to make $900 BILLION by 2026. From CEOs to Wall Street scions, everyone's piling on. One exclusive platform is poised to be at the center of it, and it wants you to be part of it. Instead of obsessing over the fluctuations in the crypto market, you can secure your wealth in the $1.7 trillion art market. Skip the 25,000-person waitlist with this special Node link.*   *See disclaimer The cryptocurrency movement has never been so sprawling, reaching every corner of the planet.   Crypto State by CoinDesk aims to connect with local communities to explore this movement of financial disruption and how it trickles down to every corner of the globe, from DeFi investment opportunities to alternative ways to transact and store wealth.    We're making virtual stops with audiences in Nigeria, the Middle East and Southeast Asia this year. Register for the Crypto State virtual tour. Putting the news in perspective The Takeaway Bitcoin Is Batman™ According to philosopher Craig Warmke, Bitcoin is basically Batman. Well, I may be taking a bit of liberty with Warmke's argument.  The assistant professor of philosophy at Northern Illinois University and a member of the crypto-oriented research collective Resistance Money has a forthcoming paper which contends that Bitcoin is a collective story that all participants in the network participate in writing. We all endlessly discuss "What Is Bitcoin," and it doesn't appear that even the maximalists have settled on a consensus answer.   Warmke's conception of Bitcoin as a collective fiction is, if nothing else, novel in the corpus of explanations. Note that the argument here isn't saying Bitcoin is like a story.   He's saying it is a story, one that happens to also have value in the real world. This isn't so hard to understand, as we'll see.  Bitcoin is a story and bitcoin is the story's main subject. As stories go, it's pretty boring. It's the story of new bitcoin getting issued and then moving from one wallet to another – forever. The plot is: Bitcoin moves around within Bitcoin. Scintillating! The Bitcoin network uses writing (code) to describe something with no external correspondence, and yet it has value. That's fiction. As Warmke puts it toward the end of the paper, "If the chunk of code in the Bitcoin blockchain that describes a movement of bitcoin is not itself that movement, where does the movement, the transaction, take place? Nowhere – or everywhere, depending on how you think of it… Bitcoin is a fictional substance." In his conception, miners are publishers and nodes are referees. Wallet owners have the right to write but only so long as they have some fictional bitcoin to compose a sentence about, and the only thing that sentence can say is how much bitcoin is going to a certain wallet.  But … fiction? So let me give you my way of thinking about Warmke's paper by way of the Caped Crusader: It helps to explain why Bitcoin is like Batman™. Batman is also a fictional object within a story. It is an extremely valuable story, in fact. The 1989 "Batman" sparked a global pop culture sensation and netted over $400 million at the box office. The "Dark Knight" film trilogy was worth $2.5 billion in revenue to Warner Bros. at the box office alone, and that's just recent proceeds, just from the films.  The Caped Crusader has been printing money for its owners across books, toys and other media since 1939. Beat that, Satoshi! What non-comic book fans may not realize is that Batman's value has persisted in part because his story has persisted in part because that story keeps growing (much like Bitcoin's). The Batman story continues each month, all over the pages of DC Comics where he appears an impossible number of times in numerous titles, new bits of story coming out every week. Bob Kane and Bill Finger are credited with inventing Batman, but his legend has grown as countless writers, artists and editors add to the massive Batman mythology.  Each Batman story effectively becomes a bit of "real" history. In fact, every single thing that happens in any DC comic book is part of the history of the world that Batman lives in, and those histories frequently bleed into each other.  Once a DC superhero comic book is published, it becomes canon and any other writer can pick up where that story left off, even if done in the pages of a whole other title. The term-of-art in comics for this is "continuity." It's another way of saying "history of a fictional world." In other words, writers and artists have something like writing rights in the collective story of a comic book universe but, also like in Bitcoin, there are limitations. Writers and artists are like the wallets in Warmke's conception, adding sentences to the Batman ledger.  But editors are like bitcoin nodes. Their job is, in part, to guard against continuity errors in Batman's history (making sure a new story doesn't contradict an old one, for example) and to make sure consensus gets maintained around Batman.  There are an infinite number of Batman stories, but that infinite set is not unbounded.  If a writer came in one day with a script where Bruce Wayne decided to open a flower shop rather than fight crime, I would expect the editor would reject that story. Such a story, one might say, would break consensus about the character of Batman. We like a story in which a character surprises us, but only if it surprises us in a way that still feels right. That's the consensus part. "Batman: Caped Chrysanthemum Curator" would surprise readers in a bad way. Furthering Warmke's framework here, obviously, DC Comics is Batman's publisher, his equivalent of a mining network (much more centralized). Diamond Comics Distributors is his internet, the Batman distribution network.  Both very valuable This network keeps the thing that is Batman™ moving forward, a story that keeps growing. It's a much more interesting story than reading the Bitcoin ledger. And for different reasons, those stories have real value in the real world. But they are still stories. At the end of the day, this is an ontological argument about what it means for something to exist, and Warmke has constructed a thought-provoking model here that might drive consensus around that "is" question about Bitcoin. The next time people ask you: "What Is Bitcoin?" you can tell them: "It's a story that's written collectively by all the bitcoin holders. It gets more valuable the more people know about it, help write it and the longer the story goes on."  Inevitably, they will counter: "How does that make sense?"  To which, we are currently prone to saying something like: "Look, money is a collective fiction, too." That's usually taken as sort of a college sophomore level cliché – it rings hollow every time.   But now you can say: "Obviously, it's just like Batman." That should get their attention.   –Brady Dale The Chaser... ATTENTION: Scammers have been sending fraudulent emails with links to sites disguised to look like coindesk.com. If you are in doubt about a link, type https://www.coindesk.com directly into your browser; do not copy and paste. Remember, if something seems too good to be true, it probably is. The Node   A newsletter from CoinDesk   See Previous Editions Copyright © 2021 CoinDesk, All rights reserved.    250 Park Avenue South New York, NY 10003, USA You can manage your preferences here or unsubscribe from all CoinDesk email.